Rev. Henry Colman 1807–1820
Rev. Charles Brooks 1821–1838
Rev. Oliver Stearns 1839–1856
Rev. Daniel Bowen 1859–1863
Rev. Joshua Young 1864–1868
Rev. John Snyder 1869–1872
Rev. William G. Todd 1873–1875
Rev. Henry A. Miles, D.D. 1876–1883
Rev. Alexander T. Bowser 1884–1887
Rev. Charles T. Billings 1890–1896
Rev. Charles H. Porter, Jr. 1897–1900
Rev. Charles E. Park 1900–1906
Rev. Paul S. Phalen 1908–1912
Rev. George B. Spurr 1913–1918
Rev. Edward P. Daniels 1919–1928
Rev. R. Lester Mondale 1929–1930
Rev. Cornelius Heyn 1930–1932
Rev. Abbot Peterson 1932–1935
Rev. Curtis Spence 1935–1941
Rev. W. Wallace Bush 1941–1944
Rev. Rowland Gray-Smith 1944–1959
Rev. Richard Kimball 1959–1960
Rev. Paul R. Adkins 1970–1974
Rev. Jackson McKinley Smith 1974–1987
Rev. Maureen Young Manns 1988–1995
Rev. Thomas F. Kepler 1995–2007
Rev. William Turpie 2007–2016
Rev. Steven M. Aucella 2017–present
